Last month a founder explained his refund spike to us in one sentence. He runs a high-ticket coaching business doing low eight figures a year. Monthly refunds had climbed to three or four times their usual level.
Over a couple of years, the core offer had more than doubled in price. What a student actually received after paying had barely moved.
What made this hard to catch was the bank balance. High-ticket programs collect upfront, so every price increase lands in the account the day the sale closes. When we asked how the business felt from the inside, he said “looking straight at our cash, you’re like, oh, yeah, things are great.” On a cash view, he was right.
The cost of those increases arrived months later and in a different place. It showed up as refunds, which sit on their own line in the P&L with nothing connecting them back to the pricing decision that caused them. It also showed up as coaching hours spent on students who felt they had overpaid. Nobody records that time as a cost of pricing, so it quietly inflates delivery cost and the price increase still looks like a win in the monthly review.
We’ve seen this with two clients in the last few months. Prices go up, and sometimes conversion dips right away. Refunds almost always follow a few months later. A student paying twice as much expects a noticeably better experience, and when the program feels identical, a share of them will ask for their money back.
Until the program catches up with the price, part of the revenue a price increase appears to add is a refund you haven’t processed yet.
This matters most when you’re planning forward. The same business plans to raise prices again by around 30%, and next year’s growth target leans heavily on that increase. If the program upgrade ships after the new price instead of before it, the refund pattern repeats at a higher price point and every forecast built on that revenue is overstated from the start.
With this client, the new price doesn’t launch until the upgrade does. We’re also modelling the increase with an expected refund rate attached, instead of treating the new price as clean revenue. That one adjustment changes how much of the growth target the price rise can realistically carry.
Agency owners see a version of the same thing when retainers rise and the scope and service stay as they were. There it tends to surface as churn at renewal rather than refunds, but the timing gap is identical.
None of this means you should hold your prices. Most business owners we work with are undercharging. A higher price simply comes with a higher expectation, and the business has to be built to meet it. We wrote a longer piece on how to factor that into a price increase before you announce it: read the full article here.
Look at your last price increase. What changed in the offer at the same time?
If the honest answer is “not much”, reply and tell us what your refunds (or renewals) have done since. Happy to think it through with you. Schedule a time below and we’ll map it out: Let’s Talk!
If you’re in the agency world, I recently put together a full guide on scaling from $1M to $5M without burning out, covering the hidden financial traps. You can read it here:
The Ultimate Guide to FP&A for Agencies and Consultancies in 2026
Want forward-looking numbers you can act on? See how our FP&A service works.